6/27/2025
From NABIP’s newsletter
Link to the announcement: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/06/25/2025-11606/patient-protection-and-affordable-care-act-marketplace-integrity-and-affordability
CMS Finalizes Rule on ACA Marketplace Integrity
CMS has finalized the Marketplace Integrity and Affordability rule, implementing several policy changes affecting brokers, agents, and the individual market.
A key provision lowers the evidentiary standard for terminating broker and web-broker participation agreements—from requiring clear and convincing evidence to a “preponderance of the evidence” threshold. NABIP strongly supports addressing the wave of unauthorized plan switching that occurred throughout last OEP and fraud, waste, and abuse in the system. However, NABIP raised significant concerns with this provision, warning that it could lead to more arbitrary enforcement decisions. CMS’s own data shows that over 70% of terminations since April 2024 were later overturned, highlighting serious flaws in the current enforcement process and reinforcing NABIP’s concerns of unintended disruptions to both consumers and agents.
Another major change allows issuers to require payment of past-due premiums—including those owed to another issuer in the same corporate family—before effectuating new coverage. NABIP supported targeting abuse of guaranteed availability but urged CMS to limit this policy to the same product line (e.g., medical-to-medical) to prevent consumers from losing major health coverage over small balances on ancillary plans like vision or dental.
Other finalized provisions reflect CMS’s heightened focus on program integrity. Starting in 2026, a $5 minimum premium will be required for auto-reenrolled plans to prevent consumers from unknowingly remaining in $0 premium plans and incurring tax liabilities. CMS also eliminated the monthly special enrollment period (SEP) for individuals under 150% FPL—citing misuse in non-expansion states—and reinstated pre-enrollment verification for 75% of SEP enrollments. While NABIP supported stricter verification standards and a return to a one-year tax reconciliation policy, it flagged concerns that a shortened Open Enrollment window and growing documentation requirements may overwhelm broker capacity. CMS has finalized a November 1–December 15 OEP for 2027 and beyond but has left room for states to adjust to a 9-week period. Many provisions sunset after 2026, as CMS seeks to rebalance the market following the expiration of enhanced tax credits. NABIP will continue to advocate for balanced enforcement, consumer protections, and the vital role of licensed brokers.

